UNDERSTANDING TAXATION OF TRUST IN INDIA.
India follows the English concept of a trust as a vehicle under which
property is alienated from the original owners and held by a trustee for the
benefit of others. The law governing trusts is codified and contained in the
Indian Trust Act.
A “trust” is an obligation annexed to the ownership of property and
arising out of a confidence reposed in and accepted by the owner, or declare
and accepted by him, for the benefit of another, or of another and the owner.
Author of trust:- the person who reposes or declares the
confidence is called “author of the trust”. Trustee:- The person
who accepts the confidence is called the “trustee”.
Beneficiaries:- The person for whose benefits the confidence is accepted is called
the “beneficiary”.
Trust property:- The subject matter of the trust is called the “trust property” or
“trust money”.
Instrument of trust:- The instrument, if any, by which the trust is
declared is called the “instrument of trust”.
Public trust are generally formed for charitable or religious purposes, and are
not intended to do commercial activities. A public charitable trust is one,
which benefits the public at large, or some considerable portion of it. While,
the income from private trusts is available to specified
beneficiaries and not to the public at large.
A charitable trust is defined to include relief of the poor,
education, medical relief, and the advancement of any other object of general
public utility. Promotion of sports and games is considered to be a charitable
purpose.
The public or private trust, differ in the process of their creation. In
creating a charitable or religious trust, a formal deed or any other writing is
not necessary, even if it involves immovable property. It may be created by use
of words, but what is necessary is that there should be divestment of property
on the part of the author or the settlor of the trust and should vest in the
trustee, a third person.
Private trusts are created and governed by the provisions of the Indian
Trusts Act, 1882 , whereas charitable trusts are beyond this
Act. The Act applies to whole of India except when specifically amended by any
State Government.
Taxation of Private Trust.
·
When the shares of the individual beneficiaries are
determinate:-
·
The shares falling to each of the beneficiaries are liable to be
assessed, either in the hands of the trustee(s) as a representative assessee or
directly in the hands of the beneficiary entitled to the income. Such assessment
is made at the rate applicable to the total income of each beneficiary.
·
Where the income of the trust consists of or includes profits and gains
of business, income tax shall be charged in the hands of trustee(s) on the
whole of the income at the maximum marginal rate. This provision is not
applicable, in the case of a trust which has been declared by any person
exclusively for the benefit of any relative dependent on him and also such
trust is the only trust so declared by him.
·
When the individual shares of the beneficiaries are
indeterminate or unknown [under section
164]:-
·
Trustee(s) is liable to tax as a representative assesses.
·
Where the income consists of, or includes, profits and gains of
business, the entire income of the trust is charged at the maximum marginal
rate of tax, except in cases of the a trust which has been declared by any
person exclusively for the benefit of any relative dependent on him and also
such trust is the only trust so declared by him.
·
Where the income does not consist or include profits and gains of
business, income is chargeable at the maximum marginal tax rate.
·
However, the maximum marginal rate of tax is not
applicable in the following cases, and the income will be chargeable to tax as
if it were income of an association of persons(AOP) :-
1. Where none of the
beneficiaries has any other income chargeable to tax under the Income Tax Act
and none of the beneficiaries is a beneficiary under any other trust or
2. Where the relevant
income or part of relevant income is receivable under a trust declared by any
person by will and such trust is the only trust so declared by him or
3. Where the trust is
a non-testamentary trust created before March 1, 1970 for the exclusive benefit
of relatives of the settlor mainly dependent on him for their supporter maintenance
or, where settlor is a Hindu undivided family, for the exclusive benefit of its
members so dependent upon it or
4. Where the trust is
created on behalf of a provident fund, superannuation fund, gratuity fund,
pension fund or any other fund created bona fide by a person carrying on a
business or profession exclusively for the benefit of persons employed in such
business or profession.
In cases of (a), (b) and (c) supra, the relevant income is taxable in
the hands of trustees as if it were the total income of an association of
persons, while income falling under (d) supra is exempt from tax.
More Illustration on Taxation of Private Trusts:
Income from private trusts is available to specified beneficiaries and
not the public at large. Private trusts are of two basic types for Income tax
purposes:
·
Specific trusts- where the individual shares of the beneficiaries are
known and ascertainable for e.g. Mr. X creates a trust for his 5 sons and the
share of each son is mentioned in the deed as 20% each, then such trust is
known as specific trust.
·
Discretionary Trust: In this no individual shares of the beneficiaries
are mentioned in the deed and income is distributed to them on the “discretion”
of the trustee.
Needs for creating a private trust?
Trusts are created for multifarious purposes though the major reasons
being the following:
·
To hold property for present or future needs of dependents and family
members. A common example is a trust that provides for the accumulation of
income and capital for specified infant children. Subject to their maintenance
during this period, the accumulation must be handed over to them upon their
attaining a specified age or, in the case of a female beneficiary, upon
marriage; and
·
Sometimes to reduce the burden of tax.
·
Retirement trusts are commonly set up be employers to provide retirement
benefits to employees
Tax treatment of trusts:
·
Approved retirement trusts are also exempt from tax.
·
In the case of private trusts, if the individual shares of the
beneficiaries are ascertainable, they are included in the individual taxable
incomes, the tax assessment being made either directly on the beneficiary or on
the trustee as a representative of the
beneficiary. However, if the trust has income from business, the entire
income from the trust is taxed in the hands of the trustee at the maximum
marginal rate applicable to individuals unless the trust is created by will for
the benefit of relatives. When the individual shares of the beneficiaries are
indeterminate (i.e., discretionary trust), the entire income is taxed in the
hands of the trustees, in most cases at the maximum marginal rate applicable to
individuals.
See the diagram for better understanding.
Notes:
Point 1: in the following case rates applicable to Individuals will be
charged:
·
If the trust has been declared by way of a will from which business
income is derived; and
·
It is exclusively declared for the benefit of any relative dependent on
the settlor for support and maintenance; and
·
The trust is the only trust so declared by the settlor.
Point 2: in the following cases rates applicable to Individuals will be
charged:
1. Where none of the
beneficiaries
_ Has taxable income exceeding 50000.00 (for A.y.
2006-07 1 lac)
_ Is a beneficiary under any other private trust; or
2. Where the relevant
income or part of the relevant income is receivable under a trust declared by
any person by will and such trust is the only trust so declared by him; or
3. Where the trust
yielding the relevant income or part thereof was created by a non-testamentary
instrument before 1-3- 1970 and the A.O. is satisfied that it was created bona
fide for the benefit of the dependant relatives of the settlor, or where the
settlor is HUF, exclusively for the benefit of the dependant members.
4. Where the relevant
income is receivable by the trustees on behalf of a provident fund,
superannuation fund, gratuity fund or pension fund or any other fund created
bona fide by a person carrying on a business or professional exclusively for
the benefits of his employees.
Tax treatment of settlor / grantor
·
If the trust effectively alienates income from the settlor/grantor,
income tax liability thereon will be avoided.
·
However, the settlor/grantor continues to be liable to income tax on
income from the settled property to the extent that it is for the immediate or
deferred benefit of a spouse or minor child.
·
Stamp duty is payable on the transfer of immovable property.
REGISTRATION OF MINOR TRUST: Trust can be formed for a minor by
executing a deed for a specific period, say 21 years. This trust can be
registered under the Indian trust Act.
TAX IMPLICATION:
1 Tax implication every year during the period of trust: This private
trust will be taxed at a slab rate applicable for individual provided it does
not have business income.
Any business income may be taxed @ 30% or at slab rate.
2 Tax implications at the end of specified periods: At the end of
the specific period, the trust property will be transferred to the beneficiary
minor (who become major till that period) and will be a capital receipts in the
hand of beneficiary and hence not taxable.
BENEFITS:
1 Enjoy tax exemption limit and lower tax rate applicable for individual
every year.
2 Transfer of the assets of trust to beneficiary at no cost/ negligible
cost.
3 Transfer of the assets of trust to beneficiary will be tax neutral
provided he attains majority.
LIMITATIONS: Any business income of trust may be taxed @ 30%
or at slab rate.
INFORMATION AND DOCUMENTS NEEDED: Details about
trustee, beneficiary and settlor.
Taxation of Public Trust.
To find out the taxable income of a charitable or religious trust:-
·
Compute the income of a trust. Here, “income” includes voluntary
contributions received by a trust/institution created wholly or partially for
charitable or religious purposes. The income of a trust/institution is required
to be computed as per the provisions of the Income Tax Act.
·
Find out the part of income exempt under section 11 or section 12 of
the Act. Trusts/Institutions are required to register themselves under Section 12AA in
order to avail the exemptions. This can be done by writing an application
in Form 10A within
a year from the date of setting of trust/institution. Broadly, the scheme of
the provisions regarding the exemptions may be summarized as follows:-
·
The creation of trust must be wholly for charitable purposes and the
objectives of the trust should be for charitable purposes, as defined under the
Act.
·
The trust should not be created for the benefit of any particular
religious community or caste.
·
The trust should not be created for carrying on business for profit.
·
The properties settle upon the trust must be held in trust. It would not
suffice if only the income is held in trust.
·
The trust deed must contain a provision that the income of the trust or
the property held in trust would be utilized, for charitable purposes in India.
·
It should be ensured that income or property of the trust does not
ensure for the benefit of the settlor/ author of the trust or his relatives.
·
Charitable or religious trusts, which may otherwise
be eligible for tax exemption, are liable to forfeit this exemption under Section 13of
the Act. It is applicable in the following circumstances:-
·
Where the trust is created after March 31, 1962, any part of the income
of the trust ensures, under the terms of the trust deed, directly or
indirectly, for the benefit of specified categories of persons such as, the
author of the trust, trustee or manager of the trust, substantial contributor
to the trust and any relative of such author, trustee, etc.
·
Any part of the income or any property of the trust is used or applied
during the relevant year, directly or indirectly, for the benefit of specified
categories of persons.
·
The trust funds(with certain exceptions) are invested in contravention
of the investment pattern of such funds.
Where a charitable or religious trust forfeits tax exemption in the
circumstances mentioned at (a) to (c) above, the trust shall be charged to tax
at the maximum marginal rate. A trust will attract the maximum marginal rate of
tax only on that part of income which has forfeited exemption under the above
circumstances and not on the entire income of the trust.
·
Besides there are other provisions of the Act,
which are relevant to the taxability of the income of charitable or religious
trusts. These provisions are summarized as follows:-
·
Filing of return of income [Under section
139(4A)] by trustees of charitable or religious trusts if the total
income of trust exceeds the minimum amount which is chargeable to income-tax
without giving effect to provisions of Section 11 and 12. Also,
trusts/institutions whose income is exempted under Section 11 and Section 12 are
also required to file a return as assessee’s claim for exemption would be
decided by the Income Tax Department only after it has received the relevant
material from the assessee.
The return of income has to be filed along with the audit report submitted by
chartered accountants in Form 10B after
auditing accounts of various trusts/institutions.
·
Liability of trustees as ‘representative assessees’ [Under section
161] wherein they are liable to tax in their representative capacity
in respect of income of trust.
·
Under section
80G, deduction (special exemptions) in respect of donations to
certain funds, charitable institutions, etc is granted. In order to be eligible
under this section, the charitable trusts/institutions need to obtain a valid
certificate by making an application to them in Form 10G .
The form should be accompanied by following documents:-
·
Notes on activities of institutions/fund/trusts since the time of its
inception or during last three years, whichever is less and
·
Copies of accounts of trust/institution since the time of its inception
or during last three years, whichever is less.
·
Wealth tax is also not charged on properties held under trust, or other
legal obligation, for public purposes of a religious or charitable nature
under Section 5(i) of
Wealth Tax Act. In certain cases, however, Section 21A of
the Wealth Tax Act lays down that wealth of trust is chargeable to tax as if
the property is held by an individual who is a citizen of India and resident in
India for the purpose of Act.
·
Donors are given relief from income tax in respect of donations made to
institutions established in India for charitable purpose.
·
There are specific provisions relating to public charitable/religious
trusts under section 10 of
the act. The incomes of these trusts do not form part of total income or the
income of such trusts is exempt from income tax.
·
The trustees of a charitable or religious trust are required to make an
application to the prescribed authority for allotment of a Permanent Account
Number (PAN) under the provisions of Section 139A of
the Income Tax Act.
·
In certain cases, income of a charitable/religious
trust, which is not subject to exemption under section 11 or section 12,
may be chargeable to tax as if it is the income of an association of
persons(AOP):-
·
Income from property held under trust wholly for charitable or religious
purposes
·
Voluntary contributions without any direction that they shall form part
of corpus of trust or
·
Income of trust or institution being profits and gains of business which
is incidental to the attainment of the objectives of trust and separate books
of account are maintained.
Taxation of Charitable Trust.
Any income which comes from property held under any trust or institution
which works for charitable or religious purposes is exempt from income tax
point of view if the 85% of the income is spent on the charitable or religious
purposes. If the amount spent on the religious and charitable purpose goes
short to 85%, the shortfall is taxable under income tax act.
Charitable purpose has a vast topic and it includes:-
1- Relief to the poor persons
2- Educational relief
3- Medical relief
4- And the advancement for the object of general public utility.
5- Preservation of environment.
6- Preservation of places and monuments
However if advancement of general public utility carries some business
or trade and charges some fees etc, this will not be regarded as general public
utility if the total receipt of these activities exceeds Rs. 10 lakhs.
Any voluntary contribution made to hospitals and universities or
educational institution will be considered as the income of these trusts under
section 10(23C) (6) of income tax act.
Registration Process: – any registration for charitable trusts comes
under section 12AA of income tax act and it is granted from the first day of the
financial year of which the application is made for registration. The
commissioner looks all the details and then allows registration, he has the
power to cancel the registration if he is not satisfied by the nature of work
or finds work in not going accordance to the objects of trust.
The commissioner has also the power to cancel the registration of
registered trust if finds something wrong under Section 12A of income tax act.
All the charitable trust are notified by prescribed authority and also
notified by Central Government of India. This rule starts from June, 2007.
Sometimes the application of charitable trusts and relief for 80G for
the contributors rejects. If the trust wants to re appeal for the registration,
the trust can appeal lies to the income tax appellate tribunal.
The approval under section 80G in which the contributors has income tax
relief, once granted to the trusts is for lifetime unless the commissioner of
income tax cancelled the registration finding something wrong under the section
80G(5)(6) of income tax act.
The entire charitable institute which has the income more than the basic
exemption limit of income tax must audit all its account by a C.A.
For Charitable Institute investment, income tax act defines a section
11(5) and all the investment of charitable trusts must be according to this
act. Modes of investment under section 11(5) are as follows.
1- Any investment in government
certificates (saving/ small saving).
2- Deposit in post office.
3- Deposit in scheduled banks.
4- Investment in debentures whose
principal and interest amount is fully guaranteed by government.
5- Investment in unites of U.T.I.
6- Investment in purchasing some
property(immovable)
7- Investment in the shares of Public
limited company of which the shares must be retained for three years from the
date of purchase.
8- Investment in bonds of any public
limited company engaging in industrial development or residential purpose and
urban infrastructure.
10- Investments in INDRA VIKAS PATRA.
Deposit in industrial development bank of India
Any investment which a trust made which not includes in section 11(5) of
income tax act, the trusts must bring conformity with in a year from which the
investments made. Income tax will be charged at maximum marginal rate for the
non-obey results. However, this rule will not apply to
1- Any assets of the trusts and any
increment of the shares held by trusts or corpus by the way of bonus shares as
on 01-06-1973.
2- Any debentures purchased by the trusts
before 01-03-1983.
If a group of people do voluntary contribution to the trusts for
specific purpose, it won’t be include as the income of the trusts under section
11(1) (d) of income tax act.
Any business income of any trust is not come into exemption unless the business
is incidental. The profit of the business income of any charitable trusts will
be taxable and the trusts need to maintain separate books for the business
income.
Capital Gains: – profit arising from sale of long term capital assets is
called capital gains. Exemption available to charitable trusts only when the
whole net consideration is used to buy new fixed assets. If the partial amount
is invested, the remaining part of the consideration is taxable under the
income tax act.
GUPTDAN: – Guptdan is the voluntary contribution of which the trusts
have no records of the contributors. This is also called ‘anonymous donations’.
Such contribution is taxed at the rate of 30%. However, in some cases they are
exempted which are as follows.
1- Trusts or institution wholly for
religious purpose.
2- Anonymous contribution made with
specific direction that donation is for educational or medical institution runs
by the trusts.
3- In the case of partly religious, partly
charitable trusts, where donation is anonymous contribution are made for
specific educational or religious purpose; it is exempt up to 5% of the total
income of the trusts or Rs. 1 lakh whichever more is.
Electoral trusts: – electoral trusts are the trusts of political parties
and it is approved by CBDT. Any voluntary contribution made to electoral trusts
is income of the trusts and exempted from income tax from 1, April 2010.
INCOME TAX CASE LAWS ON TRUSTS:
Now let us anaylse the case laws related to trust in summarized form.
·
The CIT rejected the application for condonation of delay in filing Form
No. 10, before the expiry of time allowed u/s. 139(1) of the Act, being notice
for accumulation of income by the trust. On writ filed by the assessee trust
the High Court considering the fact that the assessee was a State Government
undertaking and has been registered u/s. 12A of the Act since many years and
also the fact that the delay in filing Form No. 10 was because the chartered
accountant of the trust was not able to finalize the accounts in time, the High
Court quashed the order of the CIT and directed him to pass appropriate orders.
Refer, Kerala Rural Employment & Welfare Society, 18 DTR 300.
·
A trust established to carry out partly charitable purposes and partly
religious purposes would be entitled to exemption u/s. 11. Refer, Society of
Presentation Sisters, 121 ITD 422.
·
Advance paid by assessee an educational institution registered under
12A, to a club towards membership fee for providing certain amenities to the
staff and students of the assessee did not attract the provisions of section 13
(1 ) (c) rws 13 (2 ) (a) as the said club is not a prohibited person as
specified in section 13 (3), .Provisions of section 13 (1 ) (d ) were also not
attracted as the said advance was neither a deposit nor an investment and
therefore , exemption under section 11 is allowable to the assessee more so
when the AO has allowed assessee’s claim of exemption under section 11 on the
same set of facts in the preceding year. Refer, Vidya Pratishthan v Dy CIT, 44
DTR 145.
·
Assessee trust established for the purpose of running hospitals, nursing
home etc, spending the income for construction of hospital building, is an
application of income for the objects of running hospitals and entitled to
exemption. Refer, CIT v Mool Chand Sharbati Devi Hospital Trust, 41 DTR (All)
153.
·
Non-filing of audit report with ROI not fatal to s. 11 exemption. Report
filed in the course of assessment proceedings should be considered. Refer, ITO
vs. Sir Kikabhai Premchand Trust.
·
Section 11(4A) and section 11(4) are complimentary to each other and
section 11(4A)n does not restrict power under section 11(4). Refer, DIT v
Willington Charitable Trust.
·
For accumulation of income under section 11(1)(a) it is to be computed
on commercial principals and not on gross receipts. Refer, ITO vg Secretary
Agriculture Produce Marketing Committee.
·
Object of setting up an educational institution is by definition ”
Charitable ” and such an entity will essentially be of Charitable Purpose.
Refer. Sikkim Manipal University of Health Medical & Technological
Sciences.
·
There is no scope to invoke provisions of section 11-4 vis a vis net
profit of GIDC. Refer, Gujrat Industrial Development Corporation v ACIT.
·
Running of an old age home with no profit motice could not be said to be
an activity in nature of trade. Refer, Kamalakar Memorial Charitable Trust v
DIT.
·
Transfer of funds by a Charitable Society to another charitable
institution is application of income as per section 11, ACIT v U P Cricket
Association.
·
Merely because surplus has arisen to assessee during its educational
activity does not mean that assessee is not existing solely for education
purpose. Refer, Gagan Education Soceity v Addl CIT.
·
Hyderabad Stock exchange is not entitled to exemption under section 11
even though its dominant purpose is general public utility. Refer, Hyderabad
Stock Exchange Limited v ADIT.
·
In the case of CIT v. Agricultural Market Committee (AP), 336 ITR 641,
it was decided that Agricultural marketing committee constituted by State to
protect agriculturists-is with the object of general public utility and
Agricultural marketing committee is a person. Hence, entitled to registration
under section 12A/12AA.
·
In the case of Director of Income tax (Exemption) vs. Sahu Jain Trust,
56 DTR 402, it was held that exemption u/s 11 cannot be denied on the ground
that trust had let out the property for efficient utilization of its assets.
·
In the case of Mehta Jivraj Makandas & Parekh Govindaji Kalyanji
Modh Vanik Vidyarthi Public Trust vs. DIT(E), ITA No. 2212/Mum/2010, dt. 11‐03‐2011, `G’ Bench, Mumbai ITAT, BCAJ
pg. 32, Vol. 43‐A, Part 1, April 2011 it was held
that Application for renewal of exemption certificate rejected for the reason
that changes made in object clause of trust without following the required
procedure, hence the trust became invalid. The Tribunal observed that only one
addition was made in the object clause, and even that remained charitable and
did not cause any detriment to original object. There was no statutory
requirement of intimating the changes except the one mentioned in the Form 10A,
and even there was no time limit. Held that revenue was not justified in
refusing to renew exemption certificate..
·
In the case of Chinnammal ENT Medical Education and Research Foundation
v. Asst. CIT (Exemption) (Chennai), it was found that Medical equipments of the
assets are being use by Private Hospitals and hence denial of exemption u/s 11
and levy of penalty is justified.
·
Form no 10 was available with the assessee before passing of the
original assessment order, hence claim of the assessee for accumulation of
income cannot be rejected merely on the ground that form no 10 was not filed
along with the return of income. Matter remanded with the direction to verify
whether assessee has made investment in accordance with the condition of cl (b)
of section 11 (2). ( A.Y 1994-95). Refer, Kandla Dock Labour Board v ITO, 62
DTR 234.
·
Imparting education with the primary purpose of earning profits cannot
be said to be a charitable activity for the purpose of Registration u/s. 12AA.
Refer, National Institute of Aeronautical Engineering, 226 CTR 582.
·
The Tribunal is fully justified in observing that the manner of
application of funds and as to whether the applicant-assessee can claim benefit
of exemption in terms of s. 11 and 12 is a question which has to be examined by
the AO at the stage when it is urged and not by the CIT when such question is
not before the CIT. The emphasize that while registration is accordance with
the provisions of s. 12, it is a condition precedent for claiming the benefits
u/s. 11 and 12, a registration itself as per s. 12A will not automatically
confer the benefits of s. 11 and 12 on a trust, but the trust will get the
benefit only on complying with the requirements of s. 11 and 12 which
compliance can be examined by the assessee authority, while processing the
return filed by the trust. Refer, Garden City Education Trust, 28 DTR 139.
·
Provision of teaching to students in preparation after admission to
professional institutions. No evidence to show registration obtained by fraud
or forgery. Cancellation of registration on ground of profit motive not
permissible. Refer, Oxford Academy, 315 ITR 382.
·
No distinction is made between charitable and religious purposes in s.
11(i)(a), and therefore, a trust which is partly religious and charitable is
entitled to exemption u/s. 11(1)(a), even otherwise, maintenance, of mosque and
church is to be treated as charitable purpose and not purely religious purpose
and therefore, exemption u/s. 11(1)(a) could not be denied to the assessee
trusts which exist for various charitable purposes besides maintenance of
chapels and mosques, on the ground they are partly charitable and partly
religious trusts, once no case is made out for application of provisions of s.
13. Refer, The Society of Presentation Sisters, 30 DTR 1.
·
In the case of Span Foundation, 17 DTR 283, it was held that, Assessee a
charitable trust constructed a building by borrowing funds from outside as well
as investing its own corpus funds. The building so constructed was let out to a
concern in which its trustees were directors. The rental income so received by
the trust was utilised for the purpose of repaying the loan. AO held that the
assessee was not entitled to benefit u/s. 11 and 12 of the Act as the rental
income received by the assessee was not utilised for the object of the trust
and also that the building so constructed was let out to the concerned in
violation of s. 13(1)(c) of the Act. On these facts the Hon’ble High Court held
that the income derived from renting out the building was used for repayment of
loans with the ultimate object of applying the income, after the loans had been
fully repaid, towards charitable objects of the trust. Therefore the
application of rental income for the repayment of loan was towards charitable
object. Further, the rent received by the trust was more than the standard rent
as computed under the rent control laws, as such, no benefit was derived by any
interested person, therefore provisions of s. 13(1)(c) were also not attracted.
·
Since objects of trust and genuineness of its activities were not in
doubt in as much as registration was granted with retrospective effect from
1-4-2007 and reasons for delay for filing of application were not false or
untrue delay was required to be condoned. Refer, Church of Our Lady of Grace,
34 SOT 315.
·
As per section 12AA(3), registration granted to any trust or society
under section 12AA(1)(b) can be cancelled only if the CIT is satisfied that the
activities of such trust or institution are not genuine or are not being
carried out in accordance with the objects thereof; registration could not be
cancelled under section 12AA(3) by merely re-examining the objects of the trust
or society. Refer, Chaturvedi Har Prasad Education Society vs. CIT, 134 TTJ
781.
·
Insertion of new clause in section 12AA(3) with effect from 1-6-2010, by
which Commissioner has got power to cancel registration granted earlier to
assessee–trust under section 12A, is not applicable retrospectively and its
operation has to be effective from date it was introduced and onwards. Merely
by granting a registration under section 12A/12AA, a trust ipso facto is not
entitled to exemption prescribed under section 11 and 12. Refer, Ajit Education
Trust vs. CIT, 42 SOT 415.
·
DIT(E) has no power to cancel the registration granted u/s 12A prior to
1-6-2010. Refer, K Verma Charitable Trust v DITE.
·
Where an assessee is registered under section 25 of Companies Act, 1956,
it in itself shows that the company intends to apply its profit in promoting
charity. And where the object of the assessee states that it shall promote
micro finance services to poor person and help them arise out of poverty, mere
surplus from such micro finance service cannot by itself be a ground to say
that no charitable purpose exists. Followed Thanthi Trust 247 ITR 785 (SC) and
Agricultural produce and market committee 291 ITR 419 (Bom.). Refer, Dish India
Micro Credit vs. CIT.
·
Rejection of application for grant of exemption u/s 10(23)(c) cannot be
a basis for cancelling registration under section 12A. Refer, The sunbeam
English School Society v CIT.
·
Loan given by educational soceity to another educational society does
not violate section 13(1)(d) read with section 11(5). Refer, Kanpur Subhash
Shiksha Samita v DCIT.
·
Donation by a charitable trust to other charitable institution cannot
result in same becoming income of assessee- trust. Refer, D D Foundation Trust
v ITO.
·
A company is also entitled to registration under provision of sec 12A.
Refer, Sri Venkateswara Bhakti Channel v ACIT.
·
Assessee engaging manufacturing and trading activities. Assessee
converting incidental objects as main objects. Assessee not satisfying first
condition of section 11(4A) – Cancellation of registration valid. Refer,
Aurolab Trust v. CIT, 12 ITR 74.
·
Registration under section 12A was rightly refused to the trust where
the trust has carried out commercial activity and did not apply the income to
fulfil the object of the trust. Refer, Society for the Small & Medium
Exporters v. Director of IT (Exemptions), 139 TTJ 218.
FAQ on TRUST.
·
Why should I create a private trust
A Private trust is created for the following reasons:
·
·
How do I register a trust:
Ø If trust property happens to be immovable property: A registered
document (trust deed) is necessary to set up a trust if immovable property is
being transferred to it. The deed should be made out on stamp paper (for stamp
duty consult your civil lawyer) and registered with the Registrar of Assurances
under the Registration Act.
Ø If trust property happens to be movable property If only
movable property is settled upon the trust, no formal document or written
agreement is necessary. All the same, it’s advisable to prepare a trust deed on
a stamp paper and have it signed by the settlor and the trustees in the
presence of a witness to avoid any subsequent disputes.
Ø Once the trust is set up, the settlor can contribute more funds
to it as and when he wants to. Even trustees, as also friends and relatives,
can gift funds to a trust. Since gift tax has been abolished, no such tax is
payable on the amount gifted to the trust.
·
FAQs:
1. What do you mean by
Trust?
·
A Trust is a transfer of property of a person to another with the
intention that it is administered for the benefit of the owner and/ or others.
·
The person who transfers the property is called a “Settlor” or “Author
of the trust” and
·
The person to whom the property is transferred is called the Trustee.
·
The person for whose benefit the trust is created is called the
“beneficiary”.
·
The property transferred for the trust is called the “Trust Property”.
2. How can I create a
trust?
A Trust is created when the Settlor indicates his intention to create a
trust. In order to create a trust you must
·
Clearly specify the trust property,
·
The purpose of the trust and
·
The beneficiaries of the Trust.
3. Who can be a
settlor?
Any person
·
Who is a major, not legally insane, insolvent or a minor may create a
trust.
·
However a minor can create a Trust with the permission of Court.
4. Who can be a
trustee?
A trustee is a person,
·
To whom the settlor transfers his property.
·
Anyone can be a trustee, but if he has to administer the properties of
the trust, then he should be eligible to enter into contracts.
·
A minor, insolvent or an insane person cannot be a trustee.
·
A person has the right to reject his trusteeship.
·
If a person accepts the trusteeship voluntarily, according to reasonable
terms he becomes a trustee and assumes all the rights, liabilities and duties
of a trustee.
5. My father
bequeathed certain property to our auditor through a will and declared the
auditor to be trustee of the property for me. After my father’s death, the
auditor had the will probated. Does that mean the auditor has accepted to be
the Trustee?
A trust is accepted either by an act or expression of an intention to be
a trustee. Here the auditor accepted to be trustee by probating the Will.
6. “A” bequeaths
ships to “B” to carry on smuggling business and use the profits arising out of
it for maintaining A’s children. Is the Trust valid?
The Trust is not valid because a Trust can be created only for a lawful
purpose.
7. What constitutes
trust property?
Trust property can be moveable or immovable property.
1. If the trust
constitutes immovable property then its transfer to the trustee must be through
a written and registered document, signed by the settlor.
2. If the trust
constitutes moveable property, delivery of such property to the trustee is
enough and there is no need for a written document.
3. What are the duties
of a trustee?
A Trustee has to:
1.fulfil the purpose of the trust.
2.obey the directions given by the settlor.
3.get acquainted with the nature and circumstances of the trust
property.
4.take required steps to preserve and protect the trust property and
defend any legal proceedings against it
5.not derive any advantage from the trust property for himself.
6.deal with the trust property as carefully as if it were his own
7.be impartial to all beneficiaries when there are more than one
8.maintain true accounts of the trust property and furnish information
to the beneficiaries on request.
9. Can a Trustee
invest the trust money?
The trustee is bound to invest the trust money when it cannot be
immediately applied to the purpose of the trust. It can be invested only in the
following manner:
1.In promissory notes, debentures, stock or other securities of any
State Government or of the Central Government of India or of the United Kingdom
of Great Britain and Ireland.
2.In bonds, debentures and annuities charged or secured by the
Parliament of UK.
3. In stock or
debentures or of shares in railway or other companies the interest of which is
guaranteed.
4. In debentures or
other securities for money issued under the authority of any Central or
Provincial or State Act.
5.On a first mortgage. If the mortgaged property is a vacant land then
the mortgaged money cannot exceed one third and if it is a building it cannot
exceed one half of the property value.
6.In units issued by the Unit Trust of India.
7.On any other security expressly authorized by the instrument of trust
or by the Central Government by notification in the Official Gazette or by any
rule which the High court may from time to time prescribe.
10. When is the trustee
liable for breach of trust?
A trustee is liable for a breach of trust only when the beneficiary or
the trust property suffers losses as a result of the breach. However when the
beneficiary fraudulently induces the trustee to commit breach of trust, or
concurs in the breach of trust or if the
beneficiary assents to the breach after it has been committed, then the
trustee is not liable for the breach of trust.
11. What are the rights
of a trustee?
The following are the rights of a trustee:
1. To have possession
of the trust property.
2. To get
reimbursement of expenses incurred in maintaining the trust property.
3. To apply to the
court, for its opinion, advice or direction in the management of the trust
property.
4. To have the
accounts of the trust property examined and settled on completion of the
duties.
5. On completion of
his duties, to have a written acknowledgement from the beneficiaries saying
there are no dues from him to the beneficiaries.
6. What are the powers
of the trustee?
The trustee is empowered to take action for the welfare of the trust
property to:
1.sell the trust property together or in lots, by public auction or
private contract. This can be sold together or at different times.
2. Do the above within
a reasonable time, i.e. sell the property and invest the trust money to
purchase any other property.
3. Convey the trust
property through a valid and registered sale deed.
4. Invest the trust
money and monitor the investments.
5. Use the trust
property for the maintenance, education or advancement of a minor beneficiary,
if any.
6. Give a written receipt
for any money, securities or other movable property, which is paid, transferred
or delivered, to him.
When there are two or more trustees, any one may be authorized to
execute the trust. In that case the authorized trustee can:
1. Accept security for
a debt,
2. Allow time for
payment of a debt,
3. Compromise,
abandon, submit to arbitration or settle any debt relating to the trust.
4. What happens if one
of several trustees dies?
If a co-trustee dies, then the remaining trustees can exercise the
powers relating to the trust and trust property.
14. What are the
disabilities of trustees?
The disabilities of a trustee are:
1.Once he has accepted the trust; he cannot refuse to act as a trustee.
2. A trustee cannot
delegate his duties to another or a co- trustee.
3. A trustee should
not use the trust property for his own profit or any other purpose, unconnected
with the trust.
4. A trustee cannot
buy the trust property on his own account or as an agent of a third person.
5. A trustee cannot
act unilaterally but must consult his cotrustees ,if any.
6. Co-trustees should
not lend the trust money to each other.
7. How does a trust
cease to exist?
A trust ceases to exist:
1. When its purpose is
completely fulfilled; or
2. When its purpose
becomes unlawful; or
3. When the
fulfillment of its purpose becomes impossible by destruction of the trust
property or by any other cause; or
4. When the trust is
expressly revoked.
5. What are the rights
of a beneficiary?
The beneficiary has the right to:
1. Enjoy the rents and
profits of the trust property.
2. Expect the trustee
to transfer the trust property to one or more beneficiary.
3. Inspect and take
copies of the instrument of trust, the documents relating to trust property and
the accounts of the trust property.
4. If for any reason
the execution of the trust by the trustee becomes impracticable the beneficiary
may institute a suit for the execution of the trust.
5. To expect the
trustee to properly protect and administer the trust property.
6. To compel the
trustee to perform his duty properly.
7. To transfer the
benefits arising out of the trust to any other person after the beneficiary
attains majority.
8. When is a trust
revoked?
When a trust is created by will, it is revocable at the pleasure of the
testator, because it does not become effective during the lifetime of the
testator.
Any other trust can be revoked in the following ways:
1.By the consent of all the beneficiaries.
2.By the settlor in exercise of powers of revocation expressly reserved
to him.
3.If the trust was created for repayment of debts, the settlor can
revoke the trust at any time irrespective of whether the debt is repaid or not.
However, if the debt is not repaid and the creditor has knowledge of the
creation of the trust, then, the trust cannot be revoked without the consent of
the creditor.
18. When can a trustee
be discharged from office?
A trustee may be discharged from his office when:
1. The trust is
dissolved.
2. The trustee
completes the duties of the trust under the terms of the trust deed.
3. A new trustee is
appointed to carry on the duties of the trust.
4. There is mutual
consent between the trustee and the beneficiary.
5. There is an order
of Court discharging the trustee of his duties.
6. When can a new
trustee be appointed?
A new trustee can be appointed when the trustee already appointed:
1.Either disclaims being a trustee or is dead.
2.Is not in India for a continuous period of six months or leaves India
for the purpose of residing abroad.
3. Is declared an
insolvent.
4. Desires to be
discharged from the duties of the trust.
5. Becomes incapable
of acting as trustee.
Private
Trust – Succession Planning as well as Ring Fencing, Tax Planning
Unlike a Will, a Private Trust works during one's lifetime
and can be easily structured to meet specific requirements. Jigar
Pathak Business today 24 march 2019
The world over there
are two preferred modes for succession planning - writing a Will or creating a
Private Trust. Both are used in India, but with increasing entrepreneurship and
complicated asset holding patterns even within families, Trusts are gaining
popularity.
A Private Trust's
ability to ring fence assets against third-party claims, especially with the
Bankruptcy Law being active since 2016, further explains the heightened
interest among wealthy Indians for setting up Private Trust.
Will Versus Trust
Private Trusts also
have an edge in some areas over traditional modes of succession planning like a
Will.
When asset-mix and
family structure is straight forward, a Will can be a simple and effective tool
for an individual to use. But, if there are many branches in a family tree and
assets are spread out across geographies, it makes sense to set up a Private
Trust. A Will needs a probate (a court certificate confirming that the Will is
genuine) after the death of the Will maker. The process to get one may be
tedious and expensive. A probate is a public document, which means it exposes
the family to public glare should there be a dispute over the assets. In such a
scenario, a Trust offers privacy.
A Will can be
challenged in the Court by any heir who is unhappy with the asset distribution.
Unfortunately, the Will drawer will not be there to clarify his choice. This
can result in bitterness among family members and lead to protracted legal
disputes. On the other hand, grounds on which a well executed Trust can be
challenged are fewer. A Will becomes active only on a Will-drawer's death, but
a Trust can be created when the person is alive.
Setting Up a Trust
A Trust is a special
vehicle in which assets are transferred by the person setting the Trust (called
settlor). Trustees manage the assets for the sole benefit of the beneficiaries.
So, the ownership of the assets moves from settlor to the trustees.
Assets or benefits
arising out of the property held by the Trust are then passed on to the beneficiaries
as spelled out in the Trust deed.
A Trust deed is an
agreement that unambiguously specifies the objective and purpose behind the
Trust. It clearly states, without any mistakes, the name of the settlor, the
trustees and the beneficiaries, as well as a list of all the assets the Trust
would hold. Assets could include immovable property, cash, car, jewellery, art
and antiques, shares, fixed deposits, among others.
The Indian Trusts Act,
1882, governs the formation of a Private Trust. To complete the legal
formality, the Trust deed has to be signed by the settlor; at least two
trustees and by at least two witnesses. The deed needs to be registered with an
appropriate authority only if an immovable property is passed on to the Trust.
It is highly advisable to take the services of a lawyer to ensure the legal
validity of the Trust deed.
A Trust ceases to
exist when its purpose is fulfilled or when it is revoked by the settlor.
A Trust can be formed
to take care of the needs of family members in the event of untimely death or
physical incapacity of the settlor. The objective may also include taking care
of a special needs child after the settlor's death. The Trust deed can provide
for milestone-based payments to cater to health, education, maintenance or support
needs of beneficiaries.
The Trust can also
have conditions - they have to be legal - that have to be met before the
trustees can pass on the benefit. "Specific conditions when the
beneficiary may, at the discretion of the trustee, be excluded as a beneficiary,
can also be defined in the Trust deed," says Gautami Gavankar, Executive
Director - Trusteeship Services, Kotak Mahindra Trusteeship Services. For
instance, there may be a condition to cut off a family member who is a
spendthrift or a substance abuser. The purpose of such conditions would be to
avoid wastage of the settlor's wealth.
A Trust can also be
formed to protect assets in cases such as paying alimony in a divorce or
third-party claims, as long as the assets are not transferred fraudulently or
with the intent to defraud the creditors.
"Many also create
a Trust for their children to protect them from a failed marriage," says
Amit Pathak, Managing Director, Warmond Trustees & Executors. "Some
parents don't want their children to receive assets quite early in their lives,
but when they attain maturity. There can be conditions to this effect,"
Pathak adds.
All this means that a
trustee's role is very important in any Trust. The Trust deed has to make clear
the duties, power, function, manner of replacement and disqualification of
trustees. A trustee can be a family member, a friend or a third-party
professional. Corporate trustees are also gaining popularity. To avoid disputes,
it is critical to appoint a trustee who is unbiased and has no vested interest.
"The dispute could be related to management of the Trust's property and
exercise of discretion (by Trustees); beneficiaries could claim that the
Trustees are not fulfilling their duties," says Varghese Thomas, Partner
at law firm J. Sagar Associates.
Trustees have a
fiduciary responsibility towards beneficiaries, and they have to act as per the
Trust's objective.
Right Structure
For a Trust to fulfil
its purpose, the structure has to be appropriate. There are various ways in
which a Trust can be designed, and there is no one size fits all. "The
dynamics of no two families are the same and therefore, the structures will
have to be decided in discussion with the family members. Typically, Indian
laws recognise the creation of revocable and irrevocable Trusts," explains
Gavankar.
In a revocable Trust,
the settlor can recall the assets parked in the Trust at any point in time.
This means the settler doesn't lose control over the assets. In an irrevocable
Trust, assets once transferred to the Trust cannot be called back by the
settlor. Such a Trust is effective in preventing any third-party claims as the
property now belongs to the Trust and not to the settlor.
A Trust can also be
discretionary - trustees can decide the beneficiary's share. In a
non-discretionary Trust, a beneficiary's interest is pre-determined by the
Trust deed.
"An irrevocable
and discretionary Trust can protect assets from creditors, current or
potential, provided the assets have been transferred two years prior to the
bankruptcy being declared," says Sandeep Nerlekar, Managing Director and
Chief Executive Officer, Terentia, a Mumbai-based estate planning firm. He adds
that such a structure can ring fence assets against genuine business risk, but
not against fraud.
Currently, India does
not have inheritance tax, and the income generated from the Trust is liable to
taxation. Tax on the income earned from a Trust's property may be levied in the
hands of the settlor or the Trustee or the beneficiary, depending upon the structure
of the Trust used.
"Trusts do not
provide for any tax efficiency and they are more of an alternative to writing a
Will from a succession planning perspective. A Trust is only a vehicle to
ensure consolidation of assets in a single pool and therefore, the tax rates
that would be applicable in the hands of the individual would also apply to the
Trust," says Gavankar. For instance, in the case of a non-discretionary
irrevocable Trust, beneficiaries are liable to pay tax according to their tax bracket.
In a revocable Trust, the settlor is liable to pay tax according to his tax
bracket. In case of a discretionary Trust, it is the Trustees.
The primary benefit of
setting up a Trust are that the settlor can himself be one of the
beneficiaries, and be able to witness the seamless succession of wealth to the
next generation and also iron out any disputes.
A well chalked out
succession plan can help avoid family conflicts. Even worse is the possibility
that the person of your choice is deprived of the assets that you wanted to
bequeath. Anyone with a high net worth should consider setting up a Private
Trust. People spend all their lives creating assets, so it's important that
succession planning in done the right way.
Legal Paper stationary no more required
Simple format for Rental Agreement
RENTAL DEED
This
Deed of Rent made and executed at Hyderabad on 27th day of Apr 2011 by and
between: Sri M. Praneetha, aged
about: 30 years, Occ: Housewife, H.No.4-1'19, Flat No. 1102, Ramanthapur,
Hyderabad,
(Hereinafter called the "OWNER" which expression shall mean
and includes her heirs legal representatives and assignees etc; of the One
Part)
AND
M/s. MERIT INFRASTRUCTURES, represented by its
Proprietor Sri M Ramanjaneya Reddy S. Sri Obula Reddy, aged about: 43 years,
Occ: Business, H.No.4-119, Flat No. 1102, Ramanthapur, Hyderabad,
(
Hereinafter called the "TENANT"
which expression shall mean and includes their heirs, legal representatives and
assignees etc; of the Other Part)
Whereas the
Owner is the sole and absolute owner of the No.4-119, Flat No. 1102,
Ramanthapur, Hyderabad,
Whereas the Tenant approached the Owner to let out
the above office premises on rent and the Owner to let out the same on rent for
their office M/s. MERIT INFRASTRUCTURES on the following terms and conditions.
NOW
THIS RENTAL DEED WITNESSED AS FOLLOWS:
1. The
Owner has agree to let out on rent office No.4-119, Flat No. 1102, Ramanthapur,
Hyderabad, on a monthly rent of Rs.6000/-(Rupees Six Thousand only)
2. That
Rental Deed is with effect from 27`hday of April 2011.
3. That
the rental deed shall be for a period of 11 months only and renewal thereafter
on mutual understanding amongst the Owner and Tenants
4. That
the lessee has agreed to pay monthly rent of Rs. 6000/- (Rupees Fifteen Hundred
Only) on or before 10th day of every month and shall obtain the receipt from
the Owner
5. The
enhancement of rent will be 10% on every year.
6. That
the Owner agrees to permit the Tenant to use the premises to carry on the
business of Telecommunications. .
7. That
the Tenant shall pay the electricity consumption charges in respect of the
electricity Consumed for the said premises.
8. That
the property tax shall be borne by the Owner
9. The
tenant is not allowed to sublet the premises or part of the premises to any
third party.
10. That
if the Tenant commits defaults in payment of monthly-agreed amount or
contravene the terms agreed hereto, the Owner should be entitled to terminate
the Tenancy and take back the possession of the premises and recover the amount
due.
11. That
the Tenant shall not make any structural additions, alterations on the said
land expect with the written permission of Owner if, any additions, alteration
made by the Tenant with the permission of Owner shall be done, at cost of
Owner.
12. On
breach of any conditions aforementioned this Rental Deed shall stand revoked at
once and shall deliver vacant possession to the Owner with Three months notice
on demand of the either side.
In witnesses whereof the parties hereto have signed
on the day, the month and the year stated above.
WITNESSES :
1.
OWNER
(M.PRANEETHA)
2
TENANT
M/s
MERIT INFRASTRUCTURES
(M. Ramanjaneya Reddy)
HOW DOES ONE COUNTRY RECOGNISE OTHER COUNTRIES DOCUMENTS AS IDENTITY PROOF AND ADDRESS PROOF : APOSTILLE STAMP